Answers/The movement queries
Why a privacy tool with an account is a contradiction in terms
An account is a record — with your email address, your IP, your usage pattern, your billing history — held by the company you are trusting with your privacy. That record can be subpoenaed, breached, joined against other records, or used by the company itself as a policy decision changes. For a general-purpose service the tradeoff is fine; for a tool whose whole job is your privacy, it is a design contradiction.
What accounts unavoidably hold
Even a well-intentioned zero-knowledge service still knows: that you have an account, when you log in, from where, how much data you have (approximately), and often a family tree of every device you've used. None of that is your files; all of it is a shape you've handed over.
The alternative
A tool that requires no login, holds no record, and does not know you exist between one use and the next. Payment happens once, in a way that does not tie a receipt to a usage database. This is Elba's shape: buy the file, use the file, no account anywhere.
Questions people actually ask
- Aren't accounts convenient?
- Yes — that's why they're common. Convenience and privacy trade off; a privacy tool should pick privacy.
- How do you handle updates without an account?
- You come back and download the newer file when you want to. Nothing checks in from your side.
Take the island
Elba is one HTML file. It runs locally in a Chromium browser, seals a folder with AES-256-GCM, never phones home, and becomes open source on 1 January 2030.
- €49MMXXVI· now ·
- €39MMXXVII2027
- €29MMXXVIII2028
- €19MMXXIX2029
- FreeMMXXX2030
the price falls each year · free to all 1 jan 2030
pay once · no account · nothing leavesRelated answers
- 'Nothing to hide' is the wrong question — the right one is 'whose business is it?'
The 'nothing to hide' framing quietly concedes the point. A better question turns the burden around and makes the real answer obvious.
- A password vault you buy once — no subscription, no monthly fee
Encryption software you own outright, not rent. What one-time-purchase file vaults actually cost, and what you're trading for the lower price.